Overleg:Maria Radner
Laatste reactie: 9 jaar geleden door CookieMonster755 in het onderwerp Birthdate
Birthdate bewerken
Hello. There is a disbute about her birthdate. According to her management website, she was born May 7, 1981. But according to the New York Times, she was 34 years old when she passed away, which would make her not born in May, and according to Opera Online, she was born on January 1, 1981 (if so, she would be 34, like the New York Times said). Please update the article with her correct birthdate, because that's what her opera management website said. If you have questions, please reply to me. Thanks.
- New York Times source, claiming she was 34 when she passed away
- Opera online, claiming she was born on January 1, 1981
- Her opera mangement website, saying she was born on May 7, 1981.
Regards. CookieMonster755 (overleg) 26 mrt 2015 22:15 (CET)
- This is very strange: the original given birthdate here was January 1st, following the mentioned source: Le Monde. Now you changed it to May 7th - why is that? I would never trust her management for these sort of data - I have seen similar cases with e.g. Amélie Nothomb. Paul Brussel (overleg) 27 mrt 2015 00:13 (CET)
- Paul Brussel - Well May 7 is her birthdate on English Wikipedia, German Wikipedia, French Wikipedia, Polish Wikipedia, and Italian Wikipedia. The media always gets information incorrectly when there is so much information. CookieMonster755 (overleg) 27 mrt 2015 00:23 (CET)
- On WP:NL we have the rule that other wiki's are no source for WP:NL. Le Monde, as is opera-online, is quite clear in her birthdate and, as said previously, I would never trust her management about these sort of facts, certainly not in the world of singers where it is well known that especially female singers have pretended quite often that they were younger than in reality. So please keep the date of 1st of January unless you have real good sources that it is otherwise. Paul Brussel (overleg) 27 mrt 2015 00:50 (CET) PS: now I see that it is mainly yourself who has changed the birthdate in all the other wikis and colmplaining there that I reverted here. Paul Brussel (overleg) 27 mrt 2015 08:21 (CET) PS2: a former class mate of her claimed at WP:DE that her birthday was 14 December 1981. Paul Brussel (overleg) 27 mrt 2015 08:31 (CET)
- Paul Brussel, where is the source for your claim: "a former class mate of her claimed at WP:DE that her birthday was 14 December 1981."? CookieMonster755 (overleg) 27 mrt 2015 20:22 (CET)
- Well, he gave you the source (WP:DE) and it's not his claim. Anyway, I'm sure we will be certain about her birthdate within a few days. Don't let this little dispute distract us from our thoughts about her sad fate. Hartenhof (overleg) 28 mrt 2015 00:17 (CET)
- I agree with you Hartenhof, what a very sad day. She was a beautiful singer. CookieMonster755 (overleg) 28 mrt 2015 18:35 (CET)
- Well, he gave you the source (WP:DE) and it's not his claim. Anyway, I'm sure we will be certain about her birthdate within a few days. Don't let this little dispute distract us from our thoughts about her sad fate. Hartenhof (overleg) 28 mrt 2015 00:17 (CET)
- Paul Brussel, where is the source for your claim: "a former class mate of her claimed at WP:DE that her birthday was 14 December 1981."? CookieMonster755 (overleg) 27 mrt 2015 20:22 (CET)
- On WP:NL we have the rule that other wiki's are no source for WP:NL. Le Monde, as is opera-online, is quite clear in her birthdate and, as said previously, I would never trust her management about these sort of facts, certainly not in the world of singers where it is well known that especially female singers have pretended quite often that they were younger than in reality. So please keep the date of 1st of January unless you have real good sources that it is otherwise. Paul Brussel (overleg) 27 mrt 2015 00:50 (CET) PS: now I see that it is mainly yourself who has changed the birthdate in all the other wikis and colmplaining there that I reverted here. Paul Brussel (overleg) 27 mrt 2015 08:21 (CET) PS2: a former class mate of her claimed at WP:DE that her birthday was 14 December 1981. Paul Brussel (overleg) 27 mrt 2015 08:31 (CET)
- Paul Brussel - Well May 7 is her birthdate on English Wikipedia, German Wikipedia, French Wikipedia, Polish Wikipedia, and Italian Wikipedia. The media always gets information incorrectly when there is so much information. CookieMonster755 (overleg) 27 mrt 2015 00:23 (CET)